By now just about everyone has heard the terms “celebrate diversity” and “promote multiculturalism.” I went to college too long ago to understand why we need or would want to do either.
There are several definitions of ‘celebrate’, including get drunk at a party and commemorate with ceremonies. But I suppose users of the term mean that we should extol or praise diversity. People have been different for as far back as we have knowledge that people existed. Trees are different too. Will we someday be called upon to celebrate that? I can understand the need to respect people that are different from us, but I don’t understand why we need to celebrate something that has been a part of nature for thousands of years.
In fact, it seems a little arrogant to me. Who is doing the celebrating? Do we have the consent of all ethnic or otherwise diverse groups to celebrate their diversity? I seriously doubt that the Amish people want to participate in the celebration.
I have similar reservations about promoting multiculturalism. In this usage, ‘promote’ means to help or encourage to exist or flourish. Now why in the world do we need to do that? I can understand the need to accept the fact that many cultures differ significantly from our own, and the need to treat them with the respect that they deserve. But there are plenty of different cultures in the world and in our country. I don’t see the need to create any more or help the existing ones to flourish. Again, this would seem a bit arrogant to me. If a culture can’t flourish on its own, then perhaps it’s time for it to disappear. Who are we to think that we can prop it up and help it survive? I believe that we should be promoting assimilation, not multiculturalism.
We are such naive infidels.
Multiculturalism will never work with muslims because they don’t want to fit into the Western world. They want to BE the Western world. Read this article to get the words from the horse’s mouth.
http://www.atimes.com/atimes/Front_Page/FC16Aa01.html
Hannah, thanks for your comment. I took a look at your blog and found it quite interesting. You are obviously a brave young woman to take on a new life in a new land with a small child to care for. Good luck in that endeavor. I admire your decision to assimilate into the new culture.
If you read some of my other posts you know that I tend to be exasperated by some of our recent immigrants. Unlike the Irish, Italians, and other Europeans, these new immigrants have no desire to become Americans. They endure great hardship (and some of them risk their lives) to get here and then soon after they arrive they start trying to turn America into the sorry place they left.
[...] I’m pleased to find that Dr Thomas Sowell’s thoughts on celebrating diversity are similar to mine. From his article on OpinionJournal: What is it that has made Iraq so hard to pacify, even after a swift and decisive military victory? In one word: diversity. [...]
[...] Top Posts Transcending Racial StereotypesDiversity and MulticulturalismTrans-Texas CorridorThomas Sowell on DiversityFreedom WanesThe Terminator on Global WarmingObservations on ArabsGiant Leap for Mankind?Rosie O’Donnell Rants on Gun ControlPresident Nancy Pelosi? [...]