Senator Mel Martinez clearly believes that the federal government should be in the housing business. On March 8 he released this announcement:
U.S. Senator Mel Martinez (R-FL) today joined Maryland Senator Barbara Mikulski (D-MD) in introducing the reauthorization of HOPE VI – a program that works to eliminate dilapidated and dangerous public housing, replacing it with new mixed income communities.
The senators should have taken a clue from their own announcement: “dilapidated and dangerous public housing.” Do you suppose they gave any thought to why public housing is dilapidated and dangerous? Let me offer a little help. There are two principal reasons. First, it’s run by government bureaucrats — the same kind of bureaucrats that operate the VA hospitals and try to keep illegal drugs and immigrants out of the country. Second, it’s inhabited mostly by deadbeats. That’s the reason they needed housing assistance in the first place. Putting a deadbeat in a new house is not going to mend his or her ways.
If the senators did take a clue, it seems to be that if we mix in a few non-deadbeats the deadbeats won’t be so obvious to the general public. They seem to want to hide the deadbeats among more responsible residents. But where are they going to find responsible residents who want to live on the same street with a bunch of deadbeats? Do they plan to bribe them? Perhaps they intend to integrate the deadbeats into existing neighborhoods. It’s not clear from the announcement.
“This reauthorization builds on the current program and makes it better,” said Martinez. “This isn’t just about funding the creation of public housing, it’s about community involvement. This bill requires a greater community commitment so that we’re not just rebuilding housing; we’re revitalizing neighborhoods and making them sustainable communities.”
Alright Mel! You go guy! Actually Mel, you’re beginning to look a little bufoonish. Do you really believe that a few assertions from you are going to make this happen? Have you ever seen a public housing area that didn’t turn into a ghetto within a few years? It will take more than pipe dreams to make this work.
With 14 HOPE VI grants, Florida ranks 2nd in the number of grants awarded in the nation and 10th in the amount of award dollars. Through grant awards and leveraged dollars, HOPE VI has generated over $736 million for the state of Florida.
Oh, I can see clearly now. This is about pork. You’re bringing home the bacon. The program doesn’t have to have any real chance of working as intended. It doesn’t matter if it’s unconstitutional. It has worked for you when it is approved and funded.
Before becoming a senator Martinez was the Secretary of Housing and Urban Development. That is, he has previous experience at creating ghettos. I don’t know why we even have a Department of Housing and Urban Development. Nothing in the constitution permits the federal government to provide housing to private citizens. Don’t bother pointing out the ‘provide for the general welfare’ thing. The emphasis there is on ‘general’; it doesn’t say ‘provide for the welfare of specific individuals’.